2023 RESULTS   CONF
St. John Fisher (NY) W 31-7
Mount Union L 0-28 OAC
Otterbein W 50-0 OAC
Baldwin Wallace W 42-21 OAC
John Carroll L 28-31 OAC
Wilmington W 45-15 OAC
Heidelberg W 37-14 OAC
Ohio Northern W 21-17 OAC
Capital W 45-14 OAC
Muskingum W 21-20 OAC
 
2022 RESULTS   CONF
Dubuque W 14-13
Mount Union L 7-55 OAC
Otterbein W 27-10 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 29-33 OAC
John Carroll L 10-45 OAC
Wilmington W 34-0 OAC
Heidelberg L 21-29 OAC
Ohio Northern W 27-10 OAC
Capital W 50-14 OAC
Muskingum W 38-23 OAC
 
2021 RESULTS   CONF
Dubuque L 25-30
Muskingum W 18-0 OAC
Capital W 37-7 OAC
Ohio Northern L 33-34 OAC
Heidelberg L 21-44 OAC
Wilmington W 35-7 OAC
John Carroll L 10-19 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 21-24 OAC
Otterbein W 56-7 OAC
Mount Union L 7-37 OAC
 
2020 RESULTS   CONF
Baldwin Wallace W 30-20 OAC
John Carroll L 10-34 OAC
Mount Union L 3-20 OAC
Muskingum W 29-7 OAC
Wilmington W 34-7 OAC
 
2019 RESULTS   CONF
Hiram W 41-0
Capital W 44-7 OAC
Muskingum W 31-25 OAC
Ohio Northern L 23-31 OAC
Heidelberg L 32-58 OAC
Wilmington W 35-26 OAC
John Carroll L 21-23 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 3-17 OAC
Otterbein W 21-10 OAC
Mount Union L 7-69 OAC
 
2018 RESULTS   CONF
Geneva W 35-24
Capital W 51-50 OAC
Muskingum W 46-20 OAC
Ohio Northern W 43-42 OAC
Heidelberg W 38-34 OAC
Wilmington W 63-21 OAC
John Carroll L 24-27 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 28-30 OAC
Otterbein W 43-21 OAC
Mount Union L 7-49 OAC
 
2017 RESULTS   CONF
Geneva W 26-25
Mount Union L 3-69 OAC
Muskingum W 49-25 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 24-52 OAC
John Carroll L 21-48 OAC
Wilmington W 43-33 OAC
Heidelberg W 44-21 OAC
Ohio Northern W 35-28 OAC
Capital W 49-21 OAC
Otterbein L 14-48 OAC
 
2016 RESULTS   CONF
Denison L 21-34
Mount Union L 0-56 OAC
Muskingum L 10-28 OAC
Baldwin Wallace W 62-56 OAC
John Carroll L 7-42 OAC
Wilmington W 66-23 OAC
Heidelberg L 28-41 OAC
Ohio Northern L 29-45 OAC
Capital W 27-21 OAC
Otterbein L 21-49 OAC
 
2015 RESULTS   CONF
Denison L 14-41
Otterbein L 21-31 OAC
Mount Union L 0-61 OAC
Wilmington W 34-14 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 0-38 OAC
John Carroll L 10-35 OAC
Heidelberg L 28-63 OAC
Ohio Northern L 21-62 OAC
Muskingum W 49-28 OAC
Capital L 21-28 OAC
 
2014 RESULTS   CONF
Kenyon W 29-11
Otterbein L 0-20 OAC
Mount Union L 7-63 OAC
Wilmington W 47-37 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 33-40 OAC
John Carroll L 0-80 OAC
Heidelberg L 20-40 OAC
Ohio Northern L 14-23 OAC
Muskingum L 13-17 OAC
Capital L 42-56 OAC
 
2013 RESULTS   CONF
Case Western Reserve L 16-37
Capital L 13-42 OAC
Mount Union L 14-84 OAC
Heidelberg L 17-68 OAC
John Carroll L 7-62 OAC
Ohio Northern L 0-45 OAC
Wilmington W 50-22 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 7-31 OAC
Otterbein L 21-29 OAC
Muskingum L 14-24 OAC
 
2012 RESULTS   CONF
Case Western Reserve L 23-26
Capital L 7-13 OAC
Mount Union L 0-52 OAC
Heidelberg L 24-56 OAC
John Carroll L 14-61 OAC
Ohio Northern L 14-56 OAC
Wilmington L 12-13 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 14-66 OAC
Otterbein L 20-40 OAC
Muskingum L 14-38 OAC
 
2011 RESULTS   CONF
Thiel W 32-24
Muskingum L 14-34 OAC
John Carroll L 35-37 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 7-17 OAC
Mount Union L 0-62 OAC
Wilmington W 31-6 OAC
Heidelberg L 20-42 OAC
Ohio Northern L 35-56 OAC
Otterbein W 30-27 OAC
Capital L 3-24 OAC
 
2010 RESULTS   CONF
Thiel W 28-7
Muskingum L 23-31 OAC
John Carroll L 18-24 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 9-39 OAC
Mount Union L 14-28 OAC
Wilmington W 31-28 OAC
Heidelberg L 26-49 OAC
Ohio Northern L 6-45 OAC
Otterbein L 14-21 OAC
Capital L 31-34 OAC
 
2009 RESULTS   CONF
Thiel W 20-14
Wilmington W 24-20 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 13-34 OAC
Capital L 13-37 OAC
John Carroll L 0-22 OAC
Ohio Northern L 10-41 OAC
Muskingum L 12-15 OAC
Otterbein W 25-22 OAC
Heidelberg L 14-42 OAC
Mount Union L 0-56 OAC
 
2008 RESULTS   CONF
Thiel W 21-18
Wilmington L 7-34 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 16-45 OAC
Capital L 6-38 OAC
John Carroll L 6-31 OAC
Ohio Northern L 0-28 OAC
Muskingum W 33-22 OAC
Otterbein L 0-55 OAC
Heidelberg L 40-42 OAC
Mount Union L 0-49 OAC
 
2007 RESULTS   CONF
St. John's (MN) L 14-55
Baldwin Wallace L 6-24 OAC
Otterbein L 23-41 OAC
Capital L 0-27 OAC
Muskingum W 27-21 OAC
John Carroll L 9-27 OAC
Ohio Northern L 7-14 OAC
Heidelberg W 31-23 OAC
Wilmington W 38-14 OAC
Mount Union L 0-57 OAC
 
2006 RESULTS   CONF
Emory & Henry W 28-20
Baldwin Wallace W 37-31 OAC
Otterbein L 24-27 OAC
Capital L 10-52 OAC
Muskingum W 30-10 OAC
John Carroll L 7-20 OAC
Ohio Northern W 16-6 OAC
Heidelberg W 32-17 OAC
Wilmington W 27-14 OAC
Mount Union L 17-45 OAC
 
2005 RESULTS   CONF
Emory & Henry W 25-7
Heidelberg W 46-21 OAC
John Carroll L 17-48 OAC
Otterbein L 17-31 OAC
Capital L 10-41 OAC
Mount Union L 7-59 OAC
Muskingum W 18-17 OAC
Wilmington W 18-3 OAC
Baldwin Wallace W 32-31 OAC
Ohio Northern L 7-58 OAC
 
2004 RESULTS   CONF
Dubuque W 13-8
Heidelberg W 31-8 OAC
John Carroll L 3-20 OAC
Otterbein W 24-23 OAC
Capital L 7-43 OAC
Mount Union L 0-57 OAC
Muskingum W 12-7 OAC
Wilmington W 48-7 OAC
Baldwin Wallace W 26-0 OAC
Ohio Northern L 21-28 OAC
 
2003 RESULTS   CONF
Dubuque W 40-7
Otterbein L 21-26 OAC
Capital L 13-46 OAC
Heidelberg L 13-21 OAC
John Carroll L 13-42 OAC
Ohio Northern L 13-21 OAC
Wilmington L 31-37 OAC
Mount Union L 0-55 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 15-57 OAC
Muskingum W 19-16 OAC
 
2002 RESULTS   CONF
Bluffton W 28-27
Otterbein L 27-34 OAC
Capital L 0-35 OAC
Heidelberg L 27-38 OAC
John Carroll L 0-46 OAC
Ohio Northern L 10-42 OAC
Wilmington W 32-31 OAC
Mount Union L 10-56 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 14-40 OAC
Muskingum W 31-25 OAC
 
2001 RESULTS   CONF
Bluffton W 24-13
John Carroll L 17-51 OAC
Heidelberg L 17-38 OAC
Muskingum W 31-28 OAC
Mount Union L 0-47 OAC
Capital L 13-42 OAC
Otterbein L 20-42 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 22-46 OAC
Wilmington L 16-28 OAC
Ohio Northern L 0-51 OAC
 
2000 RESULTS   CONF
Waynesburg W 31-29
John Carroll L 35-42 OAC
Heidelberg W 34-7 OAC
Muskingum L 29-31 OAC
Mount Union L 14-54 OAC
Capital W 52-20 OAC
Otterbein L 17-21 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 14-34 OAC
Wilmington L 23-39 OAC
Ohio Northern L 27-68 OAC
 
1999 RESULTS   CONF
Waynesburg L 23-28
Muskingum W 35-19 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 7-44 OAC
Ohio Northern L 10-32 OAC
John Carroll L 0-10 OAC
Heidelberg L 27-33 OAC
Mount Union L 21-56 OAC
Hiram W 38-14 OAC
Capital L 21-49 OAC
Otterbein L 14-37 OAC
 
1998 RESULTS   CONF
Waynesburg W 35-15
Muskingum W 35-7 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 28-42 OAC
Ohio Northern L 7-20 OAC
John Carroll L 21-45 OAC
Heidelberg W 38-12 OAC
Mount Union L 6-41 OAC
Hiram W 28-14 OAC
Capital W 35-7 OAC
Otterbein W 28-24 OAC
 
1997 RESULTS   CONF
Central W 10-9
Capital L 18-28 OAC
John Carroll L 12-18 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 17-35 OAC
Otterbein W 51-34 OAC
Hiram W 55-10 OAC
Ohio Northern L 14-20 OAC
Mount Union L 7-69 OAC
Heidelberg L 37-52 OAC
Muskingum W 14-12 OAC
 
1996 RESULTS   CONF
Central W 35-18
Capital W 55-0 OAC
John Carroll L 11-38 OAC
Baldwin Wallace W 43-30 OAC
Otterbein W 56-0 OAC
Hiram W 37-3 OAC
Ohio Northern L 14-26 OAC
Mount Union L 16-61 OAC
Heidelberg W 58-28 OAC
Muskingum W 30-3 OAC
 
1995 RESULTS   CONF
Thiel W 36-0
John Carroll T 21-21 OAC
Baldwin Wallace W 27-10 OAC
Hiram W 26-7 OAC
Mount Union L 37-41 OAC
Capital W 69-7 OAC
Ohio Northern W 29-27 OAC
Otterbein W 45-14 OAC
Heidelberg W 50-34 OAC
Muskingum W 24-0 OAC
 
1994 RESULTS   CONF
Thiel W 20-16
John Carroll L 14-21 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 13-36 OAC
Hiram W 24-2 OAC
Mount Union L 7-34 OAC
Capital W 48-21 OAC
Ohio Northern L 14-24 OAC
Otterbein W 42-16 OAC
Heidelberg L 15-22 OAC
Muskingum W 7-6 OAC
 
1993 RESULTS   CONF
Kenyon L 10-21
Ohio Northern L 0-23 OAC
Mount Union L 0-37 OAC
Capital L 10-14 OAC
Hiram W 10-8 OAC
Otterbein L 0-10 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 9-31 OAC
John Carroll L 13-19 OAC
Heidelberg L 6-26 OAC
Muskingum W 19-7 OAC
 
1992 RESULTS   CONF
Kenyon T 7-6
Ohio Northern L 0-21 OAC
Mount Union L 0-31 OAC
Capital W 20-0 OAC
Hiram W 13-0 OAC
Otterbein L 16-28 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 7-35 OAC
John Carroll L 6-42 OAC
Heidelberg L 14-21 OAC
Muskingum W 21-0 OAC
 
1991 RESULTS   CONF
Alma L 7-21
John Carroll L 7-42 OAC
Heidelberg L 0-48 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 13-50 OAC
Muskingum L 0-49 OAC
Hiram L 29-35 OAC
Otterbein L 21-22 OAC
Ohio Northern L 6-40 OAC
Mount Union L 6-43 OAC
Capital L 6-34 OAC
 
1990 RESULTS   CONF
Alma L 19-21
John Carroll L 7-48 OAC
Heidelberg W 10-8 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 17-45 OAC
Muskingum L 7-21 OAC
Hiram W 28-14 OAC
Otterbein L 23-24 OAC
Ohio Northern L 30-50 OAC
Mount Union L 0-58 OAC
Capital L 7-27 OAC
 
1989 RESULTS   CONF
Kalamazoo College W 31-6
Capital W 13-10 OAC
Muskingum L 20-44 OAC
John Carroll L 10-13 OAC
Heidelberg L 12-28 OAC
Otterbein L 16-19 OAC
Hiram W 13-10
Mount Union L 7-31 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 7-27 OAC
Ohio Northern L 22-24 OAC
 
1988 RESULTS   CONF
Kalamazoo College W 31-21
Capital L 14-23 OAC
Muskingum L 9-44 OAC
Wittenberg L 8-48 OAC
Heidelberg L 3-28 OAC
Otterbein W 31-27 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan L 16-31
Mount Union L 32-37 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 14-27 OAC
Ohio Northern L 12-27 OAC
 
1987 RESULTS   CONF
Bluffton L 10-21
Ohio Northern L 31-34 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 7-24 OAC
Capital L 20-24 OAC
Wittenberg L 12-31 OAC
Otterbein W 9-3 OAC
Muskingum L 24-48 OAC
Oberlin W 30-13
Heidelberg W 38-17 OAC
Mount Union L 14-33 OAC
 
1986 RESULTS   CONF
Bluffton W 31-0
Ohio Northern W 51-7 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 0-12 OAC
Capital W 23-0 OAC
Wittenberg L 0-34 OAC
Otterbein W 26-7 OAC
Muskingum L 14-41 OAC
Oberlin W 26-16
Heidelberg W 28-23 OAC
Mount Union L 0-28 OAC
 
1985 RESULTS   CONF
Capital W 11-6 OAC
Mount Union L 16-28 OAC
Heidelberg L 9-27 OAC
Mercyhurst L 14-21
Baldwin Wallace L 0-34 OAC
Ohio Northern W 30-12 OAC
Oberlin W 14-0
Muskingum L 3-27 OAC
Wittenberg L 7-13 OAC
Otterbein W 21-2 OAC
 
1984 RESULTS   CONF
Otterbein L 6-10
Capital L 21-34 OAC
Mount Union L 0-31 OAC
Heidelberg L 0-42 OAC
Mercyhurst L 3-14
Baldwin Wallace L 13-22 OAC
Wittenberg L 3-24 OAC
Ohio Northern T 3-3 OAC
Wooster W 15-12
Muskingum L 0-14 OAC
 
1983 RESULTS   CONF
Heidelberg L 0-20 OAC
Capital L 7-41 OAC
Muskingum L 9-42 OAC
Mount Union L 0-28 OAC
Wittenberg L 7-35 OAC
Ohio Northern L 0-60 OAC
Denison L 0-25 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan L 0-31 OAC
Otterbein L 14-45 OAC
 
1982 RESULTS   CONF
Heidelberg L 7-19 OAC
Capital L 2-44 OAC
Muskingum L 13-33 OAC
Mount Union L 3-57 OAC
Wittenberg L 3-65 OAC
Ohio Northern L 0-20 OAC
Denison L 10-14 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan L 7-16 OAC
Otterbein L 10-28 OAC
 
1981 RESULTS   CONF
Capital L 0-24 OAC
Muskingum L 3-17 OAC
Otterbein L 0-44 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 0-47 OAC
Kenyon L 0-20 OAC
Mount Union L 0-58 OAC
Wabash L 0-38
Heidelberg L 13-21 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan L 0-45 OAC
 
1980 RESULTS   CONF
Capital L 3-13 OAC
Muskingum L 0-21 OAC
Otterbein W 14-7 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 0-41 OAC
Kenyon L 6-17 OAC
Mount Union L 7-22 OAC
Wabash L 0-42
Heidelberg L 7-21 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan T 3-3 OAC
 
1979 RESULTS   CONF
Heidelberg W 42-12 OAC
Wittenberg L 14-53 OAC
Denison L 7-48 OAC
Kenyon W 17-16 OAC
Wooster L 6-14 OAC
Muskingum L 14-16 OAC
Otterbein L 10-11 OAC
Capital L 17-21 OAC
Heidelberg L 9-21 OAC
 
1978 RESULTS   CONF
Heidelberg W 30-14 OAC
Wittenberg L 2-21 OAC
Denison W 9-7 OAC
Kenyon W 28-3 OAC
Wooster L 0-24 OAC
Muskingum L 7-12 OAC
Otterbein W 17-3 OAC
Capital W 13-8 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan L 0-13 OAC
 
1977 RESULTS   CONF
Muskingum L 14-27 OAC
Georgetown (KY) L 21-31
Capital L 6-7 OAC
Kenyon L 6-18 OAC
Denison W 10-7 OAC
Mount Union W 20-6 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 13-27 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan W 30-21 OAC
Otterbein L 0-15 OAC
 
1976 RESULTS   CONF
Muskingum L 6-7 OAC
Georgetown (KY) L 3-34
Capital L 14-22 OAC
Kenyon W 7-6 OAC
Denison W 25-7 OAC
Mount Union W 20-7 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 0-24 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan W 34-25 OAC
Otterbein L 7-14 OAC
 
1975 RESULTS   CONF
Denison L 6-14 OAC
Capital W 28-14 OAC
Mount Union L 0-26 OAC
Ohio Northern L 26-28 OAC
Otterbein W 13-9 OAC
Wooster W 27-14 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 14-59 OAC
Heidelberg L 7-17 OAC
Muskingum W 25-20 OAC
 
1974 RESULTS   CONF
Denison L 12-21 OAC
Capital W 21-6 OAC
Mount Union W 10-7 OAC
Ohio Northern W 20-7 OAC
Otterbein L 28-29 OAC
Wooster W 21-13 OAC
Baldwin Wallace L 0-73 OAC
Heidelberg W 30-19 OAC
Muskingum W 40-27 OAC
 
1973 RESULTS   CONF
Allegheny W 23-22
Capital L 7-13 OAC
Hiram W 14-7
Heidelberg L 0-16 OAC
Otterbein W 12-10 OAC
Denison W 21-15 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan W 23-10 OAC
Anderson W 34-17
Muskingum L 7-10 OAC
Wittenberg L 7-35 OAC
 
1972 RESULTS   CONF
Allegheny W 27-7
Capital W 13-7 OAC
Hiram W 10-8
Heidelberg L 9-34 OAC
Otterbein W 42-14 OAC
Denison L 14-30 OAC
Ohio Wesleyan L 8-19 OAC
Westminster (PA) L 19-21
Muskingum L 12-41 OAC
 
1971 RESULTS   CONF
Westminster (PA) L 0-26
Muskingum W 20-7 OAC
Kenyon W 14-13 OAC
Hiram W 24-23 OAC
Capital W 27-13 OAC
Otterbein L 10-22 OAC
Mount Union L 18-29 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan L 23-24
Heidelberg L 13-21 OAC
 
1970 RESULTS   CONF
Westminster (PA) L 6-26
Muskingum L 21-27 OAC
Kenyon W 21-0 OAC
Hiram W 28-16 OAC
Capital L 30-34 OAC
Otterbein L 17-21 OAC
Mount Union L 7-14 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan W 45-20
Heidelberg W 13-12 OAC
 
1969 RESULTS   CONF
Westminster (PA) W 14-8
Muskingum L 0-17 OAC
Kenyon W 17-0 OAC
Hiram W 43-8 OAC
Capital W 10-0 OAC
Otterbein W 28-24 OAC
Mount Union W 20-12 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan W 24-0
Heidelberg W 14-12 OAC
 
1968 RESULTS   CONF
Emory & Henry L 13-32
Muskingum W 7-0 OAC
Kenyon W 21-0 OAC
Hiram W 21-7 OAC
Capital L 12-15 OAC
Otterbein W 25-6 OAC
Mount Union W 14-0 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan W 13-6
Heidelberg W 42-0 OAC
 
1967 RESULTS   CONF
Emory & Henry L 8-23
California (PA) L 26-35
Kenyon W 40-6 OAC
Hiram W 15-7 OAC
Capital L 0-31 OAC
Otterbein W 21-7 OAC
Mount Union T 0-0 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan L 10-13
Heidelberg W 6-0 OAC
 
1966 RESULTS   CONF
Hillsdale L 6-13
California (PA) W 16-0
Muskingum L 0-34 OAC
Hiram W 34-0 OAC
Capital L 0-15 OAC
Otterbein W 6-3 OAC
Mount Union L 10-20 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan W 17-0
Ashland T 7-7
 
1965 RESULTS   CONF
Hillsdale L 7-19
Susquehanna (PA) W 21-7
Muskingum L 0-47 OAC
Hiram L 7-41 OAC
Capital L 7-28 OAC
Otterbein L 0-10 OAC
Mount Union L 0-41 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan L 7-34
Ashland L 0-14
 
1964 RESULTS   CONF
California (PA) L 10-21
Susquehanna (PA) L 19-36
Muskingum L 0-21 OAC
Hiram W 13-12 OAC
Wittenberg L 0-35 OAC
Otterbein L 8-17 OAC
Capital L 0-24 OAC
Fairmont State L 13-27
Wayne State (MI) W 7-3
 
1963 RESULTS   CONF
California (PA) L 21-44
Muskingum L 12-57 OAC
Wayne State (MI) W 13-9
Hiram W 20-19 OAC
Wittenberg L 7-57 OAC
Otterbein W 14-0 OAC
Capital W 7-6 OAC
Wooster W 14-10 OAC
Heidelberg L 12-39 OAC
 
1962 RESULTS   CONF
Fairmont State L 6-14
Muskingum L 0-58 OAC
West Liberty L 7-38
Wittenberg L 0-55 OAC
Waynesburg L 12-22
Otterbein L 28-42 OAC
Capital W 29-28 OAC
Wooster L 0-52 OAC
Heidelberg L 7-20 OAC
 
1961 RESULTS   CONF
Muskingum L 0-14 OAC
Mount Union L 7-12 OAC
West Liberty L 12-21
Wittenberg L 0-52 OAC
Kenyon T 41-41 OAC
Otterbein L 8-10 OAC
Capital L 6-15 OAC
Waynesburg L 7-32
Geneva L 20-26
 
1960 RESULTS   CONF
West Virginia Wesleyan W 22-12
Muskingum L 6-64 OAC
Mount Union W 14-6 OAC
Wittenberg L 0-54 OAC
Hiram W 38-0 OAC
Kenyon W 34-12 OAC
Otterbein L 20-44 OAC
Capital W 28-15 OAC
Salem W 20-7
 
1959 RESULTS   CONF
Muskingum L 24-36 OAC
Wittenberg L 8-27 OAC
Grove City L 6-27
Hiram W 36-8 OAC
Kenyon W 44-0 OAC
Otterbein L 12-16 OAC
Capital W 22-14 OAC
Washington & Jefferson W 90-0
Bethany (WV) W 32-8
 
1958 RESULTS   CONF
West Virginia Wesleyan W 25-12
Wittenberg L 0-36 OAC
Mount Union W 14-9 OAC
Hiram W 34-14 OAC
Kenyon L 0-6 OAC
Otterbein W 14-12 OAC
Capital L 14-21 OAC
Muskingum L 16-31 OAC
Bethany (WV) W 44-36
 
1957 RESULTS   CONF
West Virginia Wesleyan W 13-12
Wittenberg L 0-27 OAC
Mount Union L 26-32 OAC
Hiram W 27-13 OAC
Bethany (WV) L 6-49
Otterbein L 13-46
Capital L 18-41 OAC
Muskingum L 0-74 OAC
 
1956 RESULTS   CONF
West Virginia Wesleyan L 0-6
Wittenberg L 6-41 OAC
Muskingum L 0-33 OAC
Otterbein L 13-26 OAC
Capital L 6-58 OAC
Bethany (WV) L 0-53
Hiram L 6-25 OAC
 
1955 RESULTS   CONF
Muskingum L 0-53 OAC
Wittenberg L 13-44 OAC
Capital L 0-37 OAC
Hiram L 0-32 OAC
Otterbein L 7-12 OAC
Ohio Northern L 0-19
Bethany (WV) L 13-27
Wilmington L 7-19
 
1954 RESULTS   CONF
Muskingum L 6-42 OAC
Wittenberg W 20-19 OAC
Capital L 0-28 OAC
Hiram T 12-12 OAC
Otterbein L 7-26 OAC
Ohio Northern W 12-0
Bethany (WV) W 13-6
Wilmington W 19-13
 
1953 RESULTS   CONF
Grove City L 0-7
Capital L 0-19 OAC
Wittenberg L 0-63 OAC
Otterbein L 7-19 OAC
Muskingum L 6-48 OAC
Bethany (WV) W 14-7
Wilmington L 7-26
 
1952 RESULTS   CONF
Grove City T 0-0
Wittenberg L 12-47
Capital L 12-49 OAC
Hiram L 6-26 OAC
Otterbein W 31-13 OAC
Muskingum L 7-36 OAC
Bethany (WV) L 0-32
Wilmington W 25-14
 
1951 RESULTS   CONF
Bethany (WV) L 6-7
Anderson W 32-13
Capital T 6-6 OAC
Wittenberg L 0-26 OAC
Otterbein L 0-22 OAC
Muskingum L 7-34 OAC
Salem W 23-0
 
1950 RESULTS   CONF
Capital W 22-7 OAC
Bethany (WV) L 0-7
Anderson W 20-7
Wittenberg L 6-34 OAC
Otterbein L 6-32 OAC
Muskingum L 7-46 OAC
Davis & Elkins L 13-40
Kent State L 0-57 OAC
 
1949 RESULTS   CONF
West Liberty L 7-19
Rio Grande (OH) W 14-7
Centre L 16-48
Wilmington L 7-13
Capital L 0-27 OAC
Wittenberg L 7-27 OAC
Bethany (WV) W 17-14
Carnegie Mellon L 7-48
 
1948 RESULTS   CONF
Centre L 6-7
Rio Grande (OH) W 19-0
Carnegie Mellon W 21-7
Capital L 6-13 OAC
Wilmington L 12-16
Wittenberg W 26-7 OAC
Wabash W 18-7
West Virginia Wesleyan L 14-33
 
1947 RESULTS   CONF
West Liberty L 6-13
Capital L 7-19 OAC
Rio Grande (OH) W 13-7
Kenyon W 20-6 OAC
Wilmington L 6-12
Wittenberg L 6-19
West Virginia Wesleyan L 0-12
 
1946 RESULTS   CONF
West Virginia Tech L 0-21
Capital W 12-0 OAC
Rio Grande (OH) L 6-7
Kenyon W 12-0 OAC
Wilmington W 18-0
Wittenberg L 0-7 OAC
West Virginia Wesleyan L 20-33
 
1945 RESULTS   CONF
no-team
 
1944 RESULTS   CONF
no-team
 
1943 RESULTS   CONF
no-team
 
1942 RESULTS   CONF
Rio Grande (OH) W 9-7
Rio Grande (OH) W 24-13
 
1941 RESULTS   CONF
Georgetown (KY) L 7-13
Wabash L 0-19
Mount Union W 7-6 OAC
Wittenberg L 0-27 OAC
Otterbein L 0-41 OAC
Denison L 0-19 OAC
Capital L 6-12 OAC
 
1940 RESULTS   CONF
Georgetown (KY) L 0-21
Capital L 6-8 OAC
Kenyon T 6-6 OAC
Rutgers L 0-53
Denison L 6-13 OAC
Otterbein W 19-0 OAC
Wittenberg L 7-26 OAC