| 2023 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Allegheny | L | 36-39 | PAC | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grove City | L | 27-43 | PAC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 10-41 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 20-31 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | L | 14-15 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | W | 24-0 | PAC | ||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 0-35 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 29-43 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 35-26 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 28-33 | PAC | ||
| 2022 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Gallaudet (DC) | W | 52-14 | |||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 31-45 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 37-30 | PAC | ||
| Allegheny | L | 15-31 | PAC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 20-27 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 34-17 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 34-8 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 10-30 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | L | 16-53 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 0-56 | PAC | ||
| 2021 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | L | 6-49 | |||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 33-66 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 52-14 | PAC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 3-39 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 0-38 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 14-66 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | L | 7-38 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 3-49 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 31-7 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 0-55 | PAC | ||
| 2020 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 0-66 | PAC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 0-51 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 7-40 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | L | 26-56 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 14-21 | PAC | ||
| 2019 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | L | 20-31 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 21-45 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 17-41 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 7-27 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 14-13 | PAC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 3-24 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 24-42 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | L | 17-21 | PAC | ||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 24-27 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 14-50 | PAC | ||
| 2018 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | L | 14-31 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 12-27 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 13-22 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 10-7 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 24-21 | PAC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | W | 24-21 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 3-28 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | W | 12-10 | PAC | ||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 17-41 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 14-33 | PAC | ||
| 2017 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | L | 0-19 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-28 | |||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 20-30 | PAC | ||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 21-56 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 14-21 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 14-35 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 7-59 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 34-7 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | W | 31-21 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 0-42 | PAC | ||
| 2016 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | L | 16-17 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-28 | |||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 23-35 | PAC | ||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 7-35 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 14-10 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 10-9 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 7-40 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | L | 42-50 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | L | 12-30 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 10-14 | PAC | ||
| 2015 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | W | 35-10 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 21-28 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 24-41 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 14-27 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 35-31 | PAC | ||
| Case Western Reserve | L | 14-45 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-24 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 28-15 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 13-42 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 23-45 | PAC | ||
| 2014 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | W | 33-0 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 35-24 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 44-38 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 27-33 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 35-0 | PAC | ||
| Case Western Reserve | W | 35-15 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 26-21 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 35-32 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 14-21 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | W | 31-28 | PAC | ||
| Buffalo State (NY) | L | 36-59 | BOWL | ||
| 2013 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | W | 21-17 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 59-49 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 23-6 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 28-49 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 35-21 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 38-0 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 20-27 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 31-14 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 38-19 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 13-38 | PAC | ||
| Brockport State (NY) | L | 12-19 | BOWL | ||
| 2012 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | W | 34-23 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 21-7 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 35-14 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | W | 14-10 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 20-19 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 21-14 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 23-21 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 21-20 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 42-16 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 14-31 | PAC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | W | 28-24 | BOWL | ||
| 2011 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Christopher Newport | L | 7-12 | |||
| Wilkes (PA) | C | ||||
| Thiel | W | 46-7 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 32-26 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 23-7 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 47-33 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 20-22 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | L | 14-17 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | W | 26-23 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 21-24 | PAC | ||
| Widener (PA) | L | 27-48 | BOWL | ||
| 2010 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Wilkes (PA) | L | 35-38 | |||
| Thiel | W | 34-6 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 42-16 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 17-24 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 55-42 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 24-23 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | W | 41-7 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 34-28 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 10-14 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 30-31 | PAC | ||
| 2009 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Wooster | W | 42-39 | |||
| Hanover | W | 49-21 | |||
| Thomas More | L | 24-47 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | W | 33-12 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 42-49 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 39-49 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 52-13 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 24-35 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 38-17 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 12-35 | PAC | ||
| 2008 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Wooster | L | 6-27 | |||
| Hanover | W | 34-32 | |||
| Thomas More | L | 26-34 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | W | 21-12 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 63-26 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | W | 34-28 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 24-31 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 19-23 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 50-35 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 9-42 | PAC | ||
| 2007 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Muskingum | W | 28-10 | |||
| Wooster | W | 45-35 | |||
| Grove City | W | 27-23 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | W | 20-6 | PAC | ||
| St. Vincent | W | 42-20 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 45-7 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 25-20 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 21-22 | PAC | ||
| Geneva | L | 17-24 | PAC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 54-13 | PAC | ||
| Dickinson (PA) | L | 10-16 | BOWL | ||
| 2006 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Wesley (DE) | L | 14-41 | |||
| Wooster | L | 10-31 | |||
| Shenandoah | L | 10-20 | |||
| Grove City | W | 29-18 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | W | 23-16 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 41-15 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 34-24 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 3-30 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | W | 21-7 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 21-9 | PAC | ||
| 2005 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Denison | L | 17-21 | |||
| Manchester | W | 28-7 | |||
| Hanover | W | 34-17 | |||
| Thomas More | L | 7-13 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 38-21 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | L | 28-35 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 6-7 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 24-35 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | L | 10-17 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 40-13 | PAC | ||
| 2004 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Denison | W | 64-0 | |||
| Randolph-Macon | W | 31-7 | |||
| Manchester | W | 73-14 | |||
| Hanover | L | 31-34 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 56-17 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | L | 20-26 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 51-14 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 30-35 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | W | 30-19 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 18-13 | PAC | ||
| Johns Hopkins (MD) | L | 23-26 | BOWL | ||
| 2003 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Denison | W | 70-14 | |||
| Randolph-Macon | W | 45-7 | |||
| Gettysburg (PA) | L | 30-31 | |||
| Alfred (NY) | W | 17-7 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 42-0 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 34-19 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 45-10 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | W | 27-17 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | W | 28-7 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 34-20 | PAC | ||
| Bridgewater | L | 24-28 | III | ||
| 2002 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Denison | W | 28-7 | |||
| Otterbein | L | 13-33 | |||
| Alfred (NY) | W | 39-3 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 42-21 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | L | 13-21 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 30-24 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 21-28 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | W | 24-21 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 29-33 | PAC | ||
| 2001 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Denison | W | 47-42 | |||
| Ursinus (PA) | L | 35-41 | |||
| Ohio Wesleyan | L | 0-27 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 7-34 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 28-6 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 21-10 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 13-62 | PAC | ||
| Juniata (PA) | L | 28-34 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 13-36 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 14-16 | PAC | ||
| 2000 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Marietta | L | 29-31 | |||
| Denison | W | 28-27 | |||
| Ohio Wesleyan | W | 28-14 | |||
| Averett | W | 39-8 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 13-3 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 34-6 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 29-32 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 6-51 | PAC | ||
| Juniata (PA) | W | 24-18 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 6-35 | PAC | ||
| 1999 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Marietta | W | 28-23 | |||
| Manchester | L | 37-39 | |||
| Gannon | W | 50-43 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 26-21 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 40-7 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 24-28 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 28-56 | PAC | ||
| Ursinus (PA) | L | 35-48 | |||
| William Paterson (NJ) | W | 48-7 | |||
| 1998 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Marietta | L | 15-35 | |||
| William Paterson (NJ) | L | 37-45 | |||
| Gannon | L | 13-26 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 21-13 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 42-0 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 33-26 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 14-26 | PAC | ||
| LaSalle | W | 20-19 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 47-28 | |||
| 1997 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| St. Francis (PA) | W | 29-6 | |||
| Alfred (NY) | W | 43-27 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 29-23 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 38-22 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | L | 30-42 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 27-28 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | L | 7-14 | |||
| LaSalle | W | 41-7 | |||
| Juniata (PA) | L | 23-26 | |||
| 1996 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| St. Francis (PA) | L | 0-27 | |||
| Alfred (NY) | L | 26-56 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 12-26 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 41-15 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 32-7 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 20-73 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | L | 24-44 | |||
| Hartwick (NY) | L | 14-42 | |||
| Juniata (PA) | L | 20-25 | |||
| 1995 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Robert Morris | L | 6-41 | |||
| Walsh | W | 37-15 | |||
| Thiel | W | 31-26 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 36-7 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 6-58 | PAC | ||
| Gannon | L | 10-14 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 16-17 | PAC | ||
| Kenyon | W | 32-3 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 20-14 | |||
| 1994 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Robert Morris | L | 19-24 | |||
| Wesley (DE) | L | 0-42 | |||
| Thiel | W | 16-0 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 24-7 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 21-59 | PAC | ||
| Gannon | W | 21-19 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 22-24 | PAC | ||
| Kenyon | L | 14-19 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 28-21 | |||
| 1993 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Gannon | L | 0-9 | |||
| Grove City | L | 22-28 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 3-41 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 14-29 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 13-28 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 32-7 | PAC | ||
| Kenyon | W | 20-12 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 24-22 | |||
| Wesley (DE) | L | 15-22 | |||
| 1992 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Urbana | L | 7-17 | |||
| Gannon | L | 3-34 | |||
| Grove City | L | 3-23 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 0-35 | PAC | ||
| Thomas More | L | 0-10 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | L | 16-27 | PAC | ||
| Thiel | W | 19-0 | PAC | ||
| Kenyon | W | 26-21 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 0-14 | |||
| 1991 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | W | 14-0 | |||
| Grove City | W | 20-12 | PAC | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 19-33 | PAC | ||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 38-15 | PAC | ||
| Duquesne | W | 20-6 | |||
| Urbana | W | 31-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-21 | |||
| Thiel | W | 32-6 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | L | 18-22 | |||
| 1990 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Washington & Jefferson | L | 9-14 | PAC | ||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 7-14 | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-24 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 44-10 | PAC | ||
| Duquesne | W | 47-7 | |||
| Mercyhurst | W | 33-8 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-20 | |||
| Thiel | W | 31-10 | PAC | ||
| Grove City | W | 24-7 | PAC | ||
| Frostburg State | W | 28-18 | |||
| 1989 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Denison | L | 0-17 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 14-27 | |||
| Mercyhurst | L | 13-34 | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-20 | |||
| Thiel | W | 12-0 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 17-3 | |||
| Bluffton | W | 42-20 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-28 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 17-16 | |||
| Grove City | L | 9-14 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 8-27 | |||
| 1988 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Liberty | L | 10-14 | |||
| Glenville State | L | 0-27 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 7-9 | |||
| Geneva | L | 23-36 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 35-14 | |||
| Bluffton | L | 0-34 | |||
| Capital | L | 7-14 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-30 | |||
| Mercyhurst | L | 17-20 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 20-9 | |||
| 1987 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Liberty | L | 14-28 | |||
| Glenville State | L | 10-22 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 22-16 | |||
| Urbana | W | 29-12 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 31-7 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 14-7 | |||
| Muskingum | W | 16-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 10-19 | |||
| Geneva | L | 8-22 | |||
| 1986 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Liberty | L | 8-23 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 12-28 | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 7-55 | |||
| Urbana | L | 10-13 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 21-20 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 14-27 | |||
| Muskingum | L | 3-21 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 10-9 | |||
| Geneva | W | 21-13 | |||
| Glenville State | W | 30-14 | |||
| 1985 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Liberty | W | 10-6 | |||
| Glenville State | W | 7-2 | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 0-42 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 26-6 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 0-12 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-38 | |||
| Grove City | L | 7-13 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 7-3 | |||
| California (PA) | L | 6-35 | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-9 | |||
| 1984 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Glenville State | L | 0-13 | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 12-37 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-31 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 21-10 | |||
| Geneva | L | 15-17 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 3-16 | |||
| Grove City | W | 30-0 | |||
| California (PA) | L | 7-14 | |||
| 1983 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Glenville State | T | 7-7 | |||
| Indiana (PA) | L | 0-21 | |||
| Fairmont State | W | 14-13 | |||
| Geneva | W | 17-6 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 23-6 | |||
| Emory & Henry | W | 24-7 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 24-17 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 2-20 | |||
| Grove City | W | 14-9 | |||
| Salem | L | 6-21 | |||
| 1982 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Glenville State | L | 7-20 | |||
| Indiana (PA) | L | 7-20 | |||
| Geneva | W | 48-18 | |||
| Lycoming (PA) | L | 0-7 | |||
| Emory & Henry | W | 20-12 | |||
| Frostburg State | T | 29-29 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 12-32 | |||
| Grove City | W | 35-13 | |||
| Salem | W | 30-0 | |||
| 1981 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Indiana (PA) | L | 8-14 | |||
| Geneva | T | 16-16 | |||
| Canisius | W | 35-14 | |||
| Lycoming (PA) | W | 34-12 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-14 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 30-8 | |||
| Mercyhurst | W | 43-20 | |||
| Grove City | L | 14-17 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 7-3 | |||
| 1980 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Indiana (PA) | L | 21-23 | |||
| Geneva | W | 24-7 | |||
| Canisius | L | 17-21 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 3-7 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 38-12 | |||
| Grove City | W | 48-0 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 21-0 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 36-3 | |||
| 1979 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 13-7 | |||
| California (PA) | L | 13-21 | |||
| Albion | W | 19-0 | |||
| Buffalo | L | 28-29 | |||
| Geneva | W | 27-21 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 8-3 | |||
| Indiana (PA) | L | 15-18 | |||
| Grove City | W | 42-3 | |||
| Duquesne | W | 41-7 | |||
| 1978 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 21-0 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 12-0 | |||
| Albion | W | 24-13 | |||
| Buffalo | W | 30-13 | |||
| Geneva | W | 13-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 10-20 | |||
| Indiana (PA) | L | 8-16 | |||
| Grove City | W | 27-0 | |||
| 1977 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 30-7 | |||
| West Liberty | W | 23-0 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 27-13 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 15-17 | |||
| Geneva | W | 26-6 | |||
| Findlay | W | 20-13 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 9-13 | |||
| Salem | W | 33-22 | |||
| Grove City | W | 24-13 | |||
| 1976 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 30-0 | |||
| West Liberty | W | 23-17 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 20-14 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-36 | |||
| Geneva | W | 42-6 | |||
| Findlay | W | 17-6 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 22-21 | |||
| Salem | L | 22-33 | |||
| Grove City | L | 3-7 | |||
| 1975 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 19-7 | |||
| West Liberty | T | 0-0 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 16-27 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 31-7 | |||
| Geneva | W | 14-7 | |||
| Slippery Rock | W | 29-7 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 13-15 | |||
| Ashland | L | 14-25 | |||
| Susquehanna (PA) | L | 13-28 | |||
| 1974 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 36-13 | |||
| West Liberty | L | 0-14 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 16-14 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 17-0 | |||
| Geneva | W | 29-6 | |||
| Slippery Rock | L | 3-41 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 26-15 | |||
| Ashland | L | 7-35 | |||
| Susquehanna (PA) | W | 11-10 | |||
| 1973 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-14 | |||
| West Liberty | W | 14-0 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 35-0 | |||
| Geneva | W | 13-0 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 6-24 | |||
| Salem | L | 0-14 | |||
| Ashland | L | 13-35 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 20-26 | |||
| 1972 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 19-28 | |||
| Edinboro | L | 6-23 | |||
| West Liberty | L | 3-21 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 11-27 | |||
| Geneva | L | 6-15 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 14-28 | |||
| Slippery Rock | L | 9-30 | |||
| Ashland | L | 0-41 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 30-16 | |||
| 1971 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 0-20 | |||
| Edinboro | L | 10-32 | |||
| Findlay | W | 7-0 | |||
| Salem | L | 0-30 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 6-34 | |||
| Geneva | L | 13-29 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 23-17 | |||
| Slippery Rock | L | 0-47 | |||
| Ashland | L | 7-45 | |||
| 1970 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 0-21 | |||
| Findlay | W | 22-7 | |||
| Eastern Michigan | L | 0-30 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 7-0 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-51 | |||
| Geneva | W | 21-7 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 28-0 | |||
| Wofford | L | 10-48 | |||
| Ashland | W | 20-15 | |||
| 1969 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 7-34 | |||
| Slippery Rock | L | 7-27 | |||
| Ohio Northern | W | 15-12 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 20-0 | |||
| Eastern Michigan | L | 0-48 | |||
| Geneva | W | 14-6 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 28-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-14 | |||
| Lock Haven | W | 14-13 | |||
| 1968 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 14-41 | |||
| Slippery Rock | W | 28-7 | |||
| Ohio Northern | W | 19-0 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 27-26 | |||
| Ashland | L | 7-16 | |||
| Geneva | W | 49-0 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 56-13 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 39-6 | |||
| Lock Haven | W | 69-0 | |||
| 1967 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Slippery Rock | W | 61-7 | |||
| Susquehanna (PA) | W | 60-0 | |||
| Ohio Northern | W | 48-13 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 81-0 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 61-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 61-7 | WPC | ||
| Geneva | W | 69-7 | WPC | ||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 42-0 | |||
| Fairmont State | L | 0-7 | |||
| 1966 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Slippery Rock | W | 31-0 | |||
| Susquehanna (PA) | W | 6-0 | |||
| Ohio Northern | W | 30-7 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 20-7 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 58-0 | |||
| Geneva | W | 54-7 | WPC | ||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 13-7 | |||
| Findlay | W | 7-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 14-13 | WPC | ||
| New Mexico Highlands | W | 30-27 | NAIA | ||
| Wisconsin-Whitewater | W | 42-21 | NAIA | ||
| 1965 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Ohio Northern | W | 21-0 | |||
| Geneva | W | 18-0 | WPC | ||
| Findlay | L | 7-35 | |||
| Juniata (PA) | W | 43-14 | |||
| California (PA) | W | 21-13 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 40-13 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 34-21 | WPC | ||
| Muskingum | L | 6-7 | |||
| Grove City | T | 13-13 | WPC | ||
| 1964 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Ohio Northern | L | 6-36 | |||
| Geneva | W | 19-6 | WPC | ||
| Lycoming (PA) | W | 18-13 | |||
| Ashland | W | 18-7 | |||
| Indiana (PA) | W | 19-13 | |||
| Frostburg State | L | 13-14 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 18-21 | WPC | ||
| Muskingum | L | 12-13 | |||
| Grove City | W | 53-0 | WPC | ||
| 1963 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | W | 12-6 | WPC | ||
| Lycoming (PA) | W | 30-12 | |||
| Carnegie Mellon | W | 34-7 | |||
| Ashland | L | 13-21 | |||
| Frostburg State | W | 28-0 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 34-26 | WPC | ||
| Muskingum | W | 24-14 | |||
| Findlay | L | 7-17 | |||
| 1962 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | W | 33-6 | WPC | ||
| Ferris State | W | 19-14 | |||
| Carnegie Mellon | W | 25-6 | WPC | ||
| St. Vincent | W | 34-14 | WPC | ||
| Marietta | W | 22-12 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 12-13 | WPC | ||
| Muskingum | L | 6-25 | |||
| Lafayette | L | 0-10 | |||
| 1961 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-14 | WPC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | W | 26-0 | WPC | ||
| Slippery Rock | W | 18-7 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 7-0 | WPC | ||
| Frostburg State | W | 24-7 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 6-7 | WPC | ||
| California (PA) | W | 12-7 | |||
| Marietta | W | 32-7 | |||
| 1960 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Grove City | T | 6-6 | WPC | ||
| Geneva | L | 6-14 | WPC | ||
| Carnegie Mellon | L | 6-14 | WPC | ||
| Slippery Rock | L | 14-27 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 7-19 | WPC | ||
| Susquehanna (PA) | L | 9-13 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 14-42 | WPC | ||
| Muskingum | L | 7-66 | |||
| Ohio Northern | L | 6-7 | |||
| 1959 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Grove City | T | 0-0 | WPC | ||
| Geneva | L | 6-41 | WPC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 6-27 | WPC | ||
| John Carroll | L | 14-33 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 0-6 | WPC | ||
| East Stroudsburg | T | 0-0 | |||
| Muskingum | L | 2-27 | |||
| Defiance | W | 27-0 | |||
| Baldwin Wallace | L | 0-42 | |||
| 1958 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Potomac State | W | 20-0 | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-27 | WPC | ||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-46 | WPC | ||
| Ohio Northern | W | 26-15 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 0-7 | WPC | ||
| East Stroudsburg | T | 0-0 | |||
| Defiance | W | 7-6 | |||
| Scranton (PA) | L | 0-21 | |||
| Central State | L | 13-26 | |||
| 1957 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | T | 19-19 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 6-13 | |||
| Edinboro | W | 13-7 | PSAC | ||
| Albright (PA) | W | 21-18 | |||
| Findlay | W | 13-6 | |||
| West Virginia Tech | L | 13-20 | |||
| Central State | L | 7-44 | |||
| 1956 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Liberty | L | 6-20 | |||
| Geneva | L | 6-12 | |||
| Kent State | L | 6-19 | |||
| West Virginia Tech | L | 13-20 | |||
| St. Vincent | T | 13-13 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 7-42 | |||
| Findlay | W | 12-7 | |||
| Charleston | L | 0-49 | |||
| 1955 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Liberty | W | 12-6 | |||
| Geneva | W | 8-7 | |||
| Wooster | L | 12-27 | |||
| Clarion | W | 33-0 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 13-7 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | T | 7-7 | |||
| Washington & Jefferson | W | 50-13 | |||
| Kent State | L | 0-14 | |||
| 1954 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | T | 0-0 | |||
| Kent State | L | 0-26 | |||
| Bowling Green | W | 12-7 | |||
| Clarion | W | 17-7 | |||
| West Virginia Tech | W | 39-14 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 23-7 | |||
| Washington & Jefferson | W | 40-12 | |||
| Virginia Tech | L | 6-20 | |||
| 1953 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Kent State | L | 10-20 | |||
| Geneva | W | 9-0 | |||
| West Virginia | L | 19-47 | |||
| Youngstown State | W | 10-7 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 12-0 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | L | 0-20 | |||
| West Virginia Tech | W | 27-0 | |||
| 1952 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Liberty | W | 27-12 | |||
| Geneva | W | 34-0 | |||
| West Virginia | L | 12-49 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 35-0 | |||
| St. Francis (PA) | W | 36-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 35-27 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 32-0 | |||
| Chincoteaque NAB (VA) | W | 41-0 | |||
| 1951 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Virginia | L | 9-20 | |||
| Geneva | W | 7-6 | |||
| West Virginia Tech | L | 14-25 | |||
| West Liberty | W | 22-0 | |||
| Bethany (WV) | W | 31-0 | |||
| St. Francis (PA) | W | 26-0 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 26-6 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 20-14 | |||
| Scranton (PA) | L | 0-12 | |||
| 1950 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | L | 6-9 | |||
| Quantico Marines (VA) | L | 7-14 | |||
| Mount St. Mary's (MD) | T | 19-19 | |||
| Niagara (NY) | L | 12-14 | |||
| West Virginia Tech | W | 25-6 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 12-0 | |||
| St. Vincent | T | 13-13 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 58-12 | |||
| 1949 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Virginia | L | 7-42 | |||
| Randolph-Macon | W | 38-6 | |||
| Geneva | T | 0-0 | |||
| Mount St. Mary's (MD) | W | 22-13 | |||
| Alliance (PA) | W | 25-13 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 0-6 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 19-0 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 27-6 | |||
| Niagara (NY) | L | 6-24 | |||
| 1948 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| West Virginia | L | 16-29 | |||
| Geneva | W | 7-6 | |||
| Randolph-Macon | W | 33-0 | |||
| Kent State | L | 7-34 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 37-7 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 6-21 | |||
| Niagara (NY) | L | 13-21 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 20-0 | |||
| Upsala (NJ) | W | 20-7 | |||
| 1947 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Rio Grande (OH) | W | 56-0 | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-26 | |||
| Alliance (PA) | W | 12-0 | |||
| West Virginia | L | 7-60 | |||
| Niagara (NY) | L | 7-26 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 0-9 | |||
| West Liberty | L | 7-19 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | W | 6-2 | |||
| St. Vincent | W | 20-14 | |||
| 1946 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-13 | |||
| West Virginia | L | 0-42 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 7-12 | |||
| West Liberty | L | 3-28 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | L | 6-13 | |||
| Niagara (NY) | L | 6-19 | |||
| Westminster (PA) | T | 0-0 | |||
| Youngstown State | L | 7-25 | |||
| 1945 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| no-team | |||||
| 1944 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| no-team | |||||
| 1943 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| no-team | |||||
| 1942 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Duquesne | L | 0-26 | |||
| Geneva | L | 0-26 | |||
| Indiana (PA) | L | 7-14 | |||
| West Liberty | W | 24-13 | |||
| West Virginia | L | 0-27 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 0-12 | |||
| Geneva | W | 29-7 | |||
| Charleston | L | 0-7 | |||
| 1941 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Duquesne | L | 2-14 | |||
| West Virginia | L | 7-13 | |||
| Potomac State | W | 25-0 | |||
| St. Vincent | L | 0-12 | |||
| Shippensburg | W | 6-0 | |||
| Youngstown State | L | 0-12 | |||
| West Chester | T | 0-0 | |||
| Geneva | W | 6-0 | |||
| West Virginia Wesleyan | W | 7-0 | |||
| 1940 | RESULTS | CONF | |||
| Youngstown State | T | 6-6 | |||
| Duquesne | L | 0-26 | |||
| Potomac State | W | 33-0 | |||
| Georgetown (DC) | L | 12-26 | |||
| Geneva | W | 10-0 | |||
| West Liberty | W | 13-0 | |||
| West Chester | W | 20-0 | |||
| Niagara (NY) | L | 6-14 | |||